When it’s cold outside, is there anything better than snuggling up with a blanket, a book or binge-worthy TV show, and a hot cup of something sweet? These cozy moments make it easy to be okay with being snowed or rained in.

If this sounds like your vibe, level up your comfy evenings (or mornings, we won’t judge!) with a hot toddy coffee. Read on for the perfect hot toddy coffee recipe, as well as some tips on how to customize it into your new favorite drink.

What Will You Need To Make a Hot Toddy Coffee?

We all know that a drink is only as good as its ingredients and the love you put into it. Luckily, we’ll help you skip all the trial and error and make it perfectly the first time.

To craft the perfect hot toddy coffee, you’ll need the following tools and ingredients:

• Freshly Brewed Mushroom Coffee: Quickly whip up some of our Mushroom Coffee+. If you don’t have any, place an order and use what’s left of your regular coffee while you wait.
• Whiskey: Choose something strong and smooth to pair with the coffee's boldness.
• Sweetener: Try honey or brown sugar for a touch of natural sweetness.
• Citrus Juice: Fresh lemon or orange juice adds a tangy twist.
• Spices: We love cinnamon and a pinch of cayenne pepper for warmth and depth.
• Optional Extras: You can use milk alternatives like oat milk, or add peppermint schnapps for a minty twist.

How To Make the Perfect Hot Toddy Coffee

Now, it’s the moment we’ve all been waiting for. This drink is like a sweater in a cup — just one sip, and you’ll be transported somewhere with a roaring fireplace, fuzzy blankets, and rolling hills of powdery snow.

Ingredients:

• Mushroom coffee
• Whiskey
• Honey or sugar
• Lemon or orange juice
• Spice of choice (consider cinnamon, clove, nutmeg, or allspice)

Instructions:

1. Brew the Coffee: Start with eight ounces of freshly brewed mushroom coffee. 
2. Combine the Base: In a heat-safe mug, mix 1.5 ounces of whiskey, one to two tablespoons of honey or brown sugar, and 1.5 ounces of fresh lemon or orange juice.
3. Add Spices: Sprinkle in a pinch of your chosen spice. Stir until the sweetener dissolves.
4. Pour the Coffee: Slowly add the hot coffee to your mixture. Stir to combine all the ingredients.
5. Garnish: Top with a lemon slice or a cinnamon stick for presentation and aroma. Serve immediately.

How Can You Customize Your Hot Toddy?

The beauty of hot toddy coffee lies in its ability to adapt. If you’re avoiding alcohol, you can skip the whiskey and go with a splash of vanilla extract for a relaxing, non-alcoholic option. If you prefer a smoother, less acidic cup, swap the brewed coffee for a cold brew concentrate mixed with hot water.

Dairy-free enjoyers can easily substitute traditional cream with oat or almond milk, which gives the drink a creamy texture without dairy. For a hint of spice, add a sprinkle of cayenne pepper or add a touch of freshly grated ginger. Or, if you’re the daring type, incorporate some peppermint schnapps or garnish your drink with fresh mint leaves.

How Can You Enhance the Flavor of Your Hot Toddy?

Making the best hot toddy coffee starts with high-quality ingredients. Choose freshly brewed coffee for a better flavor. Pre-made coffee might be convenient, but the flavor isn’t as punchy. 

When you’re selecting a whiskey, go for a well-balanced bourbon or Irish whiskey to complement the coffee’s natural richness. For sweeteners, consider maple syrup or agave nectar instead of honey for unique flavors.

Spices are another way to elevate your drink. While cinnamon is a classic choice, adding cardamom or even star anise can deepen the flavor profile. Citrus plays a key role in balancing the drink’s flavor profile, so always use fresh lemon or orange juice for the best results. 

Lastly, don’t forget presentation — garnish with a lemon slice, cinnamon stick, or even a sprinkle of cocoa powder. Serve it in a mug or a rocks glass for extra cozy vibes.

Are Hot Toddy Coffees Healthy?

While hot toddy coffee is a comfy treat, it’s important to enjoy it sparingly. The combination of caffeine and alcohol can be stimulating, so you might want to sip it slowly, especially in the evening. If you’re looking for a lighter alternative, opt for a non-alcoholic version.

Choosing natural sweeteners like honey or maple syrup over refined sugar can make the drink a little better for your health, although it’s still important not to overdo it. For those watching their calorie intake, using dairy-free alternatives like almond or oat milk keeps the drink lighter without sacrificing creaminess.

The real health benefits of a hot toddy coffee lie in the coffee you use as a base. For instance, our Mushroom Coffee+ is made with functional ingredients like collagen protein to support skin and gut health, coffee extract to encourage mental clarity, and L-theanine to support feelings of relaxation and high-quality sleep. Plus, lion’s mane mushroom encourages focus and a balanced mood while chaga mushroom supports immunity and provides antioxidants.

The Bottom Line

Hot toddy coffee is the ultimate cozy beverage — warming, flavorful, and endlessly customizable. Whether you add some anise, maple syrup, or oat milk, it’s a drink that can adapt to your mood. 

No matter how you customize it, this hot toddy coffee has the advantage of containing our benefits-packed mushroom coffee. Now, grab your favorite mug, experiment with the recipe, and make this comforting classic your own! For more coffee recipes and insights, visit our blog today.

Sources:

A Pro’s Guide to Cocktail Garnishes | Epicurious

Facts About Sugar and Sugar Substitutes | Johns Hopkins Medicine

What is the benefit of collagen in your diet? | Gundersen Health System

How To Tell The Difference Between High And Low-Quality Bourbon, According To An Expert | Tasting Table